Monday, August 4, 2025

"Colossus" at 20: How Niall Ferguson's American Empire Became Reality

 

Colossus by Niall Ferguson (2005)

The Republic Is Dead. Long Live the Empire.

In Colossus, Niall Ferguson strips away the post–Cold War illusions of American restraint and neutrality. He lays out a blunt thesis: the United States, for all its protestations, has always functioned like an empire. What makes America different, Ferguson argued in 2005, isn't a lack of imperial ambition—it’s the country’s refusal to admit it.

Ferguson saw America as an “empire in denial.” It had military bases across the globe, economic leverage everywhere, and cultural influence that dwarfed that of past empires. What it lacked, he claimed, were three key ingredients to make that empire sustainable: the will to act long-term, the cash to pay for it, and the people willing to run it.

He was half-right.

The 20 years since Colossus hit shelves have been a case study in imperial evolution. Ferguson's warnings have aged better than most predictions from that era. The United States didn’t withdraw from empire—it doubled down. But it didn’t become Rome or Britain 2.0. It became something uniquely American: an empire without borders, without colonial offices, and without a consistent moral compass.

The Will:

What Ferguson thought America lacked—imperial will—turned out to be plentiful. Not in the form of long-term strategic planning, but through endless war and intervention dressed up as counterterrorism, humanitarian action, or “democracy promotion.” Afghanistan, Iraq, Syria, drone strikes in a dozen countries. The will wasn’t missing—it just wasn’t honest about its goals.

The Cash:

Ferguson worried about imperial overreach breaking the American bank. Instead, the empire learned to run on debt. Trillions spent, deficits shrugged off. Military budgets climbed while bridges crumbled. The financial system became an extension of the empire—Wall Street as colonial administrator.

The People:

Ferguson thought Americans wouldn’t want to run the empire. But who needs boots-on-the-ground administrators when you have surveillance tech, global finance, and client states? A handful of military contractors and NGOs filled the gap. It’s empire by proxy.

And Now, 2025:

Two decades later, America looks less like the “shining city on a hill” and more like the imperial core Ferguson predicted—overextended, bureaucratically sclerotic, and increasingly indifferent to the ideals of the republic it once was. Domestic surveillance, a permanent war state, and a foreign policy driven by commercial interest (and Trump's infinite personal greed) rather than democratic values have become normalized. The line between citizen and subject is blurry. Elections feel ritualistic. Congress is performative. The courts are political. Empire has swallowed the republic.

Ferguson’s biggest miss was that he still wanted to rescue the project. He saw imperial America as a potential force for good—if only it would admit what it was and act with competence. But competence wasn’t the missing piece. Integrity was. By 2025, it’s clear: America isn’t an empire in denial anymore. It’s just an empire run by a pathetic wannabe dictator. 


"Colossus" at 20: How Niall Ferguson's American Empire Became Reality

  Colossus  by Niall Ferguson (2005) The Republic Is Dead. Long Live the Empire. In Colossus , Niall Ferguson strips away the post–Cold War ...